The Distance Between Two Giants: Shelby Foote and Walker Percy
Dear Walker,
I couldn’t be more pleased at the acceptance of your novel, though I had no doubt about it ever since I read the opening pages. What I hope now is that you’ll come off the notion that you don’t want to go on with the work. The novel is just what Lawrence called it, “the one bright book of life.”
The recipient is novelist Walker Percy; the novel in question is Percy’s seminal The Moviegoer. The letter continues thus:
By the end of the month I expect to have killed Stonewall Jackson dead as a mackerel; which makes an excellent stopping place before I tackle the complexities of the Vicksburg Campaign.
T
he letter’s author, Shelby Foote, was hard at work on his own masterpiece, The Civil War: A Narrative. His sprawling 3 volume, 1.5 million-word masterwork on the American Civil War took more than 20 years to write and is arguably the definitive work on the subject. I say “arguably” because critics assail the fact that it reads more like a novel than “proper history,” something I consider to be a success rather than a failing. If you want a line-by-line breakdown of the conflict, try some Bruce Catton. Foote, on the other hand, crafts a heartbreakingly beautiful tale of the conflict while avoiding the tacky sentimentality of Ken Burns.
Percy (the adopted nephew of Lanterns on the Levee author William Alexander Percy), on the other hand, spent years honing his fiction and working on what Foote dubbed, “his apprentice novels.” The Moviegoer, with its portrayal of New Orleans stock broker Binx Bolling’s post-war suburban ennui, would go on to win the 1961 National Book Award.
To be frank, I’m writing this entire piece to recommend Jay Tolson’s The Correspondence of Shelby Foote & Walker Percy. Though most of the correspondence is from Foote (who, as a friend accurately points out, has the definitive Southern accent — when I imagine what God must look and sound like, it’s Shelby Foote), the collection reveals a deep bond between two masters of their craft and lays bare the anxieties, failings, ambitions, and ultimate successes of two giants of literature, Southern or otherwise.
School friends from Greenville, MS, Foote and Percy keep in close contact for over 40 years. While Foote labors for decades on what he simply refers to as, “the narrative,” Percy soldiers on and writes Love in the Ruins, Lancelot, and several other novels as well as scholarly articles.
Tolson’s collection is not only valuable as a connecting thread between two sharp literary minds; the book itself is readable from cover to cover, expertly edited and footnoted with explanatory bits for the more ambiguous references. For fans of either writer, it’s a must. If you’re new to one or both, it works as a pretty good introduction to the context of the works’ creation if not the works themselves.
Further reading:
Posted: by Ryan on January 26th, 2010 under Books, History and Culture.
Tags: Books, Lanterns on the Levee, Shelby Foote, Walker Percy, William Alexander Percy
Comments: none


One of our very own,
Much of Faulkner’s work is, arguably, unfilmable. Rendering Go Down, Moses or As I Lay Dying on screen would simply show them as narratives, unable to properly convey the depth of characterization and power of his characters’ internal monologues. 1958’s
At the moment, I’m somewhere over what I believe is Pennsylvania, happily on my way out of New York and into Atlanta, and from there on my way home to north Alabama. The view is wonderful — the snowbound landscape mimics Andrew Wyeth’s subtle pallet of gentle browns, greys, blues, and broad swathes of unspoiled white. In a few hours, I’ll be home with my family on our little mountain, the last quiet hurrah of Appalachia.
George Singleton
Once again, one of the best portrayals of rural Southern life comes from Ginny Mule Pictures. The production studio behind the Oscar-winning short film
Admittedly, the film leans heavily on a performance by Hal Holbrook that is generating some Oscar buzz already. His performance alone, portraying a Depression-era farmer at the end of his days, embattled with a redneck squatter as well as his only son make That Evening Sun worth seeing. As subtle as it is powerful, Holbrook’s performance doesn’t prop up the film so much as it does steer it; That Evening Sun is written and directed well enough not to ask Holbrook to carry it on his back. Instead, the rest of the film seems to orbit his performance, the other characters darting in and out between brief flashbacks of his youth.

